Critical Recap: Critical Role C4E43 “The Water’s Edge”
Written by Dani on November 18, 2026
Hello and welcome to Critical Recap! I’m Dani Carr, the Critical Role Senior Lore Keeper. Let’s dive into Critical Role Campaign 4 Episode 43 The Water’s Edge!
ONE DAY MORE
The Schemers finish their adjustments to Bradanfall’s ferry. There is still one more day until House Tachonis arrives. They discuss whether to try to sink the boat or swap the statues (whose decoys look fantastic) and decide to try and take the guessing out of the equation by using magic. Kattigan recalls the spell locate object, which he can learn as a ranger, but he isn’t sure how to teach himself new magic. His wife taught him a bit, particularly about healing, but that’s it. Occtis encourages him to reverse engineer how he looks for clues, so Kattigan ponders the spell.
Occtis and Vaelus speak privately about the broken trust between them. He is honest about feeling foolish that she cared about protecting him and she is honest about how difficult the decision she had to make was regarding the Stone of Nightsong. She cannot prove her trustworthiness except through action and she apologizes for breaking his trust in the first place. Occtis chooses to trust her moving forward, saying they all must work together in order to make it through an encounter with his family alive.
In the morning, Kattigan figures out how to access the spell locate object. He has Julien test it for him, with Julien hiding his wedding ring in the tavern’s rafters. The ring has ‘Be MEEK’ engraved on the inside. The spell works, even allowing Kattigan to find his ring as opposed to a duplicate due to the intuitive nature of the magic. The spell will help them find the gnomish statues they are seeking. Bolaire collects tools and works on contingency plans with Pimley.
WILD THING
Vaelus goes to Kattigan and opens up about the loss of her magic. He tells her that she can become whatever she wants. She’s still an ass-kicker. Vaelus asks the name of his wife, wanting to know the names of the lost, and he tells her – the first time he’s been able to say her name without panic – and the two discuss being lost themselves. He encourages her to be whomever she is today. Their situations are similar. Vaelus shares her own lost names, her parents, sister, and brother. They speak to each other in Elvish, bonding over the knowledge that they will see their loved ones again one day.
Vaelus meditates, trying to find who she wants to be without Sylandri’s magic. She feels a connection to the fey and decides to join the Black Rabbits. They are honored to talk with her, as they know she is a Wild Thing. She did something unexpected with the Stone – they fondly call her crazy. But she is stuck in grief and it is much better to drink with them, instead. So Vaelus drinks, removing her mourning veil and losing her shoes, and discovers that she is a happy drunk. Clauny teaches her to cast misty step and she gains the feat Fey-Touched.
SNEAK PEEK
Thimble and Morgaine are still in Arderin, spying on the Tachonis caravan. The wagons are now reloaded, each weighed down, and there are more knights and two extra carriages courtesy of Castle Temwyn. They ponder whether to go to the castle to learn more, but decide to peek at the caravan instead.
Thimble finds the quartermaster and his ledger, which details twelve gifted statues – including one of a hound. They realize that Groveland may still be alive, but petrified once more. What has been remedied once can be remedied again. The two return to the Miller’s Road to join the other Schemers in Bradanfall.
A NEW THORN
Morning of 40th Trozemere arrives and the Schemers take their positions, lying in wait for the Tachonis carriages. Thimble, Vaelus, Bolaire/Pimley, Pin, Ulbid, Dame Morgaine, and Clauny are sealed into the compartment with the three decoy statues. Julien hides under the dock, Kattigan hides on a hill to watch the caravans, and Occtis is in the woods on the riverbank. They come up with a knocking signal for Julien and those in the compartment.
Kattigan sees the carriages arrive – ten in all. There is a strange addition to the knights of Sir Amaspus Emedon, a sorcerer of House Cormoray’s vassal house. He has a cobalt bottle at his side. Amaspus goes to the dock and sends a magic-seeking fog through the water and over the ferry. Pimley takes Bolaire’s mask off and Ulbid removes the magic from the statues, allowing them to stay undetected in the compartment. Amaspus then announces to the people that he is searching for Bolaire at Lady Cormoray’s behest.
RAISING THE STAKES
After two hours, the Tachonis themselves arrive, with Primus loudly announcing himself by yelling at everyone possible. They discuss the logistics of crossing with the ferry and Primus decides to send Ryah first with the troops and Seremai carriage, then Etherand and Dame Verana Seremai with the cargo and Vachari carriage, then just Amaspus for the third and fourth trips of cargo and infantry, and then Petra on the fifth and final trip. Primus himself will stay in the sky.
Kattigan searches for the gnomes and finds one on the third cargo carriage, which will be going on the fourth trip – the one with Amaspus. He then searches for Groveland and finds him in the fifth carriage, the third trip across. The Tachonis split up and Occtis hides from his father’s sight before he and Kattigan go underwater.
Meanwhile, Amaspus goes to the doc and releases a marid, wishing for it to scour the river for enemies. Julien hides on the underside of the dock, avoiding detection. The marid notices the alterations to the bottom of the ferry, but the Shire Reeve assures them that the indentations are for the ferry’s cable. The Shire Reeve distracts Amaspus by talking to him incessantly.
THE HEIST BEGINS
Julien, Kattigan, and Occtis meet beneath the ferry, warning each other about the marid and Primus. They signal the others in the compartment and Kattigan tells them about Groveland, but they all agree to focus on Ulbid’s daughters. The trips across the water begin, slow and exhausting. Finally, the fourth trip begins. They have twenty-five rounds to rescue the gnome paladins.
Vaelus uses Pimley’s boring drill, allowing Thimble and Clauny to get into the carriage. Thimble notices that Vaelus’ eyes are wreathed with fairy magic. Vaelus casts misty step, joining the two fey in the carriage. They spot the three gnome paladin statues, loose in the carriage with many other statues. Twenty rounds left.
That is it for Episode 43 of Critical Role!
FINAL THOUGHTS
- Love the scene with Vaelus and the Black Rabbits. Embrace your wild side, girl!
- Julien and Kattigan have held onto the ropes under that boat for SIX HOURS. They should level up just for that.
- Let’s go, Schemers! You can do this! Make the switch and don’t die!
Catch Episode 44 of Critical Role Campaign 4 on Thursday, November 19th at 7pm Pacific on beacon.tv, where Beacon members get access to the entire episode, podcast included! The episode will also release on twitch.tv/criticalrole and on youtube.com/criticalrole and in two parts on our podcast. Is it Thursday yet?